Ask Dr. Meg: Is It Ok to Tell People He is the Biological Father When He Is Not?

Fibs can protect kids, and hurt them. Dr. Meg helps a woman whose brother has crossed the line.
|
Last Updated
April 22, 2019
posted on
November 18, 2015
|
2
Minute Read

Dear Dr. Meg,

I struggle with fact that my brother met a young lady with two kids, they married when the kids were 13 & 17, his wife & stepdaughter suggest daily that he is the biological father, confusing mutual friends, which turns to people calling and in boxing me on, how they missed these two kids. Also my mother finds it offensive. I am often talking her down to address her frustration, but it is confusing, misleading and hurtful as if they are re-writing history. I am wrong to be upset? Is there anything I would do or say, with out looking petty.

-Frustrated Sister

Dear Frustrated Sister-

There is absolutely nothing petty about your concerns! Telling children that a man is their biologic father when he isn’t is deceitful, confusing and very painful to children. Besides these, it’s wrong.

Teenagers in particular are very vulnerable. The teen years are a time when children are moving from childhood into adulthood and a large part of this transition involves discovering their own identities. They need to know who they are becoming, what they must leave behind and how to find their own voices, thoughts, beliefs and decisions. To cause a teen to be confused about such an integral part of who they are biologically is cruel. It’s like taking a stick, inserting it into their brains and stirring around their thoughts and beliefs.

You are right to feel angry but more importantly, you need to figure out what you can do for these kids. First, ask your brother IF he is indeed the biological father. Ask privately. If he says that he is, then tell him that this should never be a public issue (as his wife is making it) but a very important and private one. If he is the father and has not been involved until now, he has some serious explaining to do to these two children.

If, however, he is not the biologic father, as you believe, then you should challenge him to teach the teens to live with truth. They know what’s up. Having his wife play this charade exposes that she is a liar, makes them not trust her and most importantly is cruel. I promise, if she is perpetuating a lie, it will come back to haunt her and him in huge ways. She might well lose her kids over this.

Dr. Meg Meeker, MD

Practicing pediatrician, parent, grandparent, coach, speaker, and author. Say hello @MegMeekerMD

You might also like...
More
Join the conversation

The Meeker Parenting Blog Comment Policy

Let’s keep this a friendly and inclusive space. A few ground rules: be respectful, stay on topic, and no spam, please.       

free video training

5 Days to Stress-Free Parenting

Revive your approach and enjoy parenting again with this FREE boot camp from one of America’s leading experts.